Letters:

February 6, 2009

Editor:

Re: Great article, auto suppliers

I work for a global auto supplier, and I am amazed at how ignorant people are when it comes to how the auto industry functions. My engineering group was 25 people 5 years ago and we serviced Ford GM and Chrysler, there are now 5 of us left all sitting in the same small office servicing the same customers. What people don't seem to understand is, our division's profit plan is based on our sales to all of our customers, if any one of them fail, profit margins are so slim that it could cause our entire division to fail, and that domino effect would happen to every one who supplies parts to the big three. It would really be scary, not everyone is cut out to build roads and bridges for the Feds.

DM - Southfield, MI

----------

January 22, 2009

Editor:

Re: Hybrids

I'm hoping that GM can get it together to make the Cadillac ConverJ a reality (It's to be hoped with a less dippy name).  A hybrid that can go 40 miles on electricity alone and looks smoking hot?  Yes, please.

Tom Pease, Beverly Hills

Ed Note: Pics of Cadillac ConverJ from the 2009 North American International Auto Show and GM

Editor:

I for one was very excited about the Volt concept but to see what they have done to it for production has completely turn me off. I would never buy it. What a shame.

Kelvin

Kelvin, thanks for your letter. We learned some more “disturbing” news about the production Volt last week.

The Volt’s gasoline engine will not recharge the batteries during daily operations. The only way you can recharge the lithium ion batteries is by plugging them in to an electrical outlet! Once you’ve driven 40 miles (approximately) on the battery pack, the gasoline engine will generate all the electricity needed to run the car.

The battery pack alone will carry you for those first 40 miles; but after that, it might as well be a brick.

The regenerative brakes will create a little charge for the batteries; but not enough to recharge them fully. So if you can’t plug in the Volt’s battery pack at night, it becomes a useless dead weight.

I wonder if the plug-in Prius, due on or before the same time as the Volt, will be the same or if the Prius will be able to recharge its own battery pack as you drive. My money is on Toyota to make the more consumer-friendly design decision.

If the Volt is the future of GM, I fear for its future!

Todd Bianco

Sr. Editor

Editor:

“America has never seen a car this size before and their first question usually isn't about (fuel) economy, it's about safety," said Dave Schembri, president of Smart USA. "And that's why we think these results are so very important."

Someone needs to educate Dave on American car history. I owned a Berkeley and had it not been for my wife expecting we’d still have it. My BF has an American Bantam which makes the Smart car look huge. The Bantams sold in the thousands during the 1930’s. I could have put a pic of them in this letter but I used the space for my beloved Berkeley instead. Berkeley Sports Car

There were other mini cars such as the Iso Isetta manufactured by BMW as the Isetta and imported by the thousands during the late forties and early fifties., the Messerschmitt two-seater manufactured by the famous manufacturer of Nazi fighter aircraft in WW II and lest we not forget the Crosley which was manufactured from 1939 to 1952 in Cincinnati, Ohio and Marion, Indiana. Variants were raced in the SCCA’s Class H (the Crosley Hot Shot still holds all the records) and campaigned by Nick Braje who made speed equipment for the tiny 4 cylinder engine. And I guess the Fiat Topolino (had one of those too) and the Honda 600 were mentioned while “Dumb Ass Dave” slept in class.

It’s so typical of these corporate Gen X’s to pontificate without having a fucking clue about history. Dave Schembri is an example of putting his mouth in gear before his brain is running.  P.S., I’d take a Crosley Hot Shot any day over this “Smart Car piece of crap. Not only would a Hot Shot run circles around this Smart Car but it would also get better mileage doing it and be a hell of a lot more fun to drive.

Thanks for letting me rant.

John D.


John - thanks for the letter and the history lesson. But the reality is that most Americans don't remember the little British cars from the past.

Obviously, there is a weight and fuel economy penalty for modern cars with a full array of safety equipment including high-strength steel, air bags, safety belts, crash/crumple zones, etc. Plus the old cars didn't have things like power steering, brakes and windows. And what person in LA would give up a good HVAC and infotainment system? I'm disappointed with the little Smart's fuel economy (33/41).  Those numbers aren't very good for a 1 liter 3 cylinder gasoline engine and would never be acceptable outside the US.

If you want to learn more about Berkeley sports cars, you can check out the Berkeley fan club's website.

Todd Bianco
Senior Editor